An analysis of the effects of reason and emotions in knowledge and belief

My approach begins by inquiring into the fact of disagreement and asks: These rational disagreements occur because all rational participants eventually run out of reasons for justifying their beliefs.

This article as originally published in Inquiry: Furthermore, once we recognize that any reciprocal set of thought--feeling--desire may be either rational or irrational, we recognize that there is no reason to locate rationality in thoughts in themselves, nor emotions in non-cognitive structures in themselves.

Positive, negative or neutral emotion induced paired with a Wason selection task that had positive, negative or neutral problem content.

But rational debates, when pursued to the end, can reach points where there is rational disagreement. This kind of analysis in the psychology of belief has been done for some of the Western tradition's greatest thinkers. Moreover, seeing the world in a self-serving way, it routinely distorts information and ignores relevant information when working through a problem or issue.

This denied non-rational basis of belief is an essential part of the knowing process. Furthermore, the role of the affective dimension, of feelings and desires, in forming these mental constructs cannot be underestimated. The main questions I am concerned with are: How can I alter my thinking so as to alter this feeling.

A similar analysis could be given for any other emotion e. This article as originally published in Inquiry: For example, whenever I hear someone decry abortion as the killing of a human life, I always feel defensive and mount my pro-choice defense either out loud or in my mind.

Thus, threat-confirming participants select the card that confirms rather than falsifies their fears about the anticipated illness.

Critical Thinking and Emotional Intelligence

Positive, negative or neutral emotion induced paired with a Wason selection task that had positive, negative or neutral problem content. Of course there are other reasons for the urgency to be heard: Thus, one side of the card presents the truth or falsity of the antecedent e.

Yet it is commonly stated by the most accomplished practitioners of reasoning that when we try to ground our beliefs using reason we all reach a point where we have no reasons left.

The reflective investigations that I am proposing can alter what thinkers' believe and know and the prioritization of their criteria of knowing.

We are capable of becoming non-egocentric people, both intellectually and "morally.

Critical Thinking and Emotional Intelligence

What do I mean by this?. The first is the context (so to speak) of the theory, the part which his analysis of belief plays in the whole argument of Part iii of Book I of the Treatise.

The conclusions he reaches about belief in Sections 7–10 are going to be used later, in his analysis of the Idea of Necessary Connection in Section ).

This is why Seneca condemned emotions such as anger. ‘‘Reason herself, to whom the reins of power have been entrusted, in fact central to the place of both emotions and beliefs in human functioning. It can be argued that they are in no way restricted to is a difference between knowledge and belief that is of psychological.

Belief reasoning and emotion understanding in bilinguals. Belief reasoning and emotion understanding in monolinguals are positively correlated with language acquisition (de Villiers, de Villiers, J. (). The interface of language and theory of mind. Lecture 7: Hume's Analysis of Belief Hume's analysis of Belief in the Treatise of Human Nature 1 is familiar to all students of philosophy, and has been discussed so often that the reader may well think there is nothing more to be said about it.

But of course, there are few dualists left; our understanding of mental processes is much more physically-based, so we need a more satisfactory answer. To the new generation of neuroscientists, the gap between emotion and reason is narrowing – and to some, there no longer is a gap.

Critical thinking, I believe, is the only plausible vehicle by means of which we could bring intelligence to bear upon our emotional life. It is critical thinking I shall argue, and critical thinking alone, which enables us to take active command of not only our thoughts, but our feelings, emotions, and desires as well.

An analysis of the effects of reason and emotions in knowledge and belief
Rated 4/5 based on 98 review
Emotions and Beliefs: How Feelings Influence Thoughts - Google Books